What Darwin Got Wrong

This is not a book about God, or about intelligent design. Rather, here is a remarkable book, one that dares to challenge natural selectionnot in the name of religion but in the name of good science. Most scientists are so terrified of religious attacks on the theory of evolution that it is never examined critically. But there are major scientific and philosophical problems with the theory of natural selection. Darwin claimed the factors that determine the course of evolution are very largely environmental. This is a thesis that empirical results in biology are increasingly calling into question. The authors show that Darwinism is committed to inferring, from the premise that a kind of creature with a certain trait was selected, the conclusion that that kind of creature was selected for having that trait. Though such inferences are fallacious, they are nevertheless unavoidable within the Darwinist framework. Ultimately, Jerry Fodor and Massimo Piattelli-Palmarini level a devastating critique against Darwinist orthodoxy and suggest new ways of thinking about evolution. Fodor first presented his critique in theLondon Review of Books, in an article that generated heated discussion on both sides of the Atlantic.What Darwin Got Wrongis certain to be as controversial as it is precisely argued.